In Compliance: The Compliance Information Resource for Electrical Engineers logo
The Risks of
Optional Safety
Is Mandatory Safety Better?
PLUS
Cellular Approvals and RCM Certification
in Australia

Controlling Static Electricity:
A 50-Year History

Contact Burn Injuries:
The Influence of Object Thermal Mass

PLUS
Cellular Approvals and RCM Certification
in Australia

Controlling Static Electricity:
A 50-Year History

Contact Burn Injuries:
The Influence of Object Thermal Mass

May 2021
May 2021
Volume 13 l Number 5
Contents
Is Mandatory Safety Better?
By Kenneth Ross
This article discusses the legal and practical issues around the duty to design a safe product and how to decide whether various safety features that aren’t always necessary must be sold as standard features or whether they can be sold separately as options.
By Shaun Reid
Compliance requirements for cellular devices that connect to the mobile phone networks in Australia are similar to those in other countries but with some important differences. In this article, we detail the unique aspects of ACMA technical regulations.
By David E. Swenson, John Kinnear, and the ESDA
Our knowledge of ESD and how to control it has grown significantly over the past 50 years. This article maps the history of that journey.
By May Yen, Francesco Colella, Harri Kytomaa, Boyd Allin, and Alex Ockfen
This article identifies the burn injury threshold conditions associated with finite thermal mass objects and presents a model for predicting the degree of burn injury.
a hand reaching for different options on digital icons
outline of Australia with blue circles connected by lines inside
hand holding a lightning bolt
Warning side for burning your hand
In Compliance logo
In Compliance Magazine
ISSN 1948-8254 (print)
ISSN 1948-8262 (online)
is published by

Same Page Publishing Inc.
451 King Street, #458
Littleton, MA 01460
tel: (978) 486-4684
fax: (978) 486-4691

©Copyright 2021 Same Page Publishing, Inc. all rights reserved

Contents may not be reproduced in any form without the prior consent of the publisher.
While every attempt is made to provide accurate information, neither the publisher nor the authors accept any liability for errors or omissions.

editor/
publisher
Lorie Nichols
lorie.nichols@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7777
business development director
Sharon Smith
sharon.smith@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7722
production director
Erin C. Feeney
erin.feeney@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7756
marketing director
Ashleigh O’Connor
ashleigh.oconnor@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7788
circulation director
Alexis Evangelous
alexis.evangelous@incompliancemag.com
(978) 486-4684
features editor
William von Achen
bill.vonachen@incompliancemag.com
(978) 486-4684
senior contributors
Bruce Archambeault
bruce@brucearch.com
Leonard Eisner
Leo@EisnerSafety.com
Daryl Gerke
dgerke@emiguru.com
columns contributors
EMC Concepts Explained
Bogdan Adamczyk
adamczyb@gvsu.edu
Hot Topics in ESD
EOS/ESD Association, Inc
info@esda.org
advertising
For information about advertising contact Sharon Smith at sharon.smith@incompliancemag.com.
subscriptions
In Compliance Magazine subscriptions are free to qualified subscribers in North America.
Subscriptions outside North America are $129 for 12 issues. The digital edition is free.
Please contact our circulation department at circulation@incompliancemag.com
compliance news
FCC Moves Forward with Efforts to Revoke Authorizations Issued to China Telecom Carriers
The U.S. Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is continuing with its efforts to secure the nation’s telecom networks by initiating proceedings that would revoke the decades-old authorization of three telecommunications carriers with ties to China from operating in the U.S.

In a press release issued by the FCC, the FCC named three carriers, China Unicom Americas, Pacific Networks, and ComNet, which it says are owned and controlled by the government of the People’s Republic of China.

In response to the substantial evolution of security threats in the past few years, the Commission has raised concerns about the vulnerability of Chinese state-owned enterprises to direct control by the government. Last year, the FCC requested that each of the three companies show cause why the Commission should not revoke their authorizations under its Section 214 authority…

Upward Radar Device Submitted to FCC for Approval
A drone technology company has filed a request with the U.S. Federal Communications Commission to approve a new “upward radar” device that can potentially be used in advanced drone-related scanning operations.

According to an article posted on the Drone DJ website, the upward radar device is based on a new technology developed by DJI, an established drone company based in Guangdong, China. It is described in the company’s FCC filing as “DXX – Part 15 Low Power Communication Device Transmitter,” which operates on the 24.15 GHz frequency…

3 panel black and white Dilbert Comic Strip
DILBERT © 2021 Scott Adams. Used By permission of ANDREWS MCMEEL SYNDICATION. All rights reserved.
Feature Article
The Risks of Optional Safety
Is Mandatory Safety Better?
By Kenneth Ross
hand reaches for floating icons
W

e all remember when Sears sold products as “good,” “better,” and “best.” Many times, the more expensive products had better quality and, sometimes, better safety. When airbags were first sold on U.S. automobiles, they were optional. They didn’t become mandatory until the U.S. government required it. And even today, you can buy a car with two airbags or some with in excess of ten airbags. It is a rational assumption that the more airbags your car has, the safer it is.

Some reasons for differences in the safety of products include multi-functional uses of the product where some safety devices are not necessary, different price points, requests by customers, adoption of safety improvements, and inconsistent regulations and standards between the U.S. and foreign countries.

The issue of the level of safety to which your products must be designed is intertwined with the two issues that will be discussed in this article. First, is it permissible to sell similar products with different levels of safety? Second, if you do, how do you minimize risk and is it permissible to sell one product with optional safety features? Both issues have generated quite different answers from the courts, making it difficult to decide what to do.

AR logo
AR logo
AR logo
rf/microwave instrumentation
Other ar divisions: modular rf sunar rf motion ar europe
We’re with you all the way
We’re with you all the way
rf/microwave instrumentation
Other ar divisions: modular rf sunar rf motion ar europe
Safety Managers are some of our biggest fans
Safety Managers are some of our biggest fans
AR supplied test chambers provide performance and peace of mind in a single solution.

Our patented and re-retardant absorbers are RoHS and REACH compliant; they do not release carbon dust nor carry heavy poisonous chemicals.

With our pan-type RF shielding construction and absorbers that don’t absorb humidity, your test measurement accuracy is preserved over time.

To find out more about the dependable choice in chambers and absorbers, visit www.arworld.us/chambers or call 215-723-8181.

AR supplied test chambers provide performance and peace of mind in a single solution.

Our patented and re-retardant absorbers are RoHS and REACH compliant; they do not release carbon dust nor carry heavy poisonous chemicals.

With our pan-type RF shielding construction and absorbers that don’t absorb humidity, your test measurement accuracy is preserved over time.

To find out more about the dependable choice in chambers and absorbers, visit www.arworld.us/chambers or call 215-723-8181.

Vitrek logo
DL Series Electronic DC Load
The Industry’s Easiest-To-Use DC Load!
Ideal for testing DC Power Sources, DC-DC Converters & LED Drivers!
Vitrek leverages the latest innovations in electronics to provide you with extremely accurate, feature-rich and high quality electrical test equipment at a price that seems too good to be true!
  • Three power ratings available – 125W, 250W & 500W
  • Input Voltage options – 0-150V or 0-500V
  • Variety of loading sequences in single or arbitrary sequences of up to 100 steps
  • High speed performance from flexible operating modes using any combination of:
– Constant Voltage (CV)
– Constant Resistance (CR)
– Constant Current (CC)
– Constant Power (CW)
  • Three power ratings available – 125W, 250W & 500W
  • Input Voltage options – 0-150V or 0-500V
  • Variety of loading sequences in single or arbitrary sequences of up to 100 steps
  • High speed performance from flexible operating modes using any combination of:

– Constant Voltage (CV)
– Constant Resistance (CR)
– Constant Current (CC)
– Constant Power (CW)

Virtek DL Series Electronic DC Load
Feature Article
Cellular Approvals and RCM Certification in Australia
By Shaun Reid
map of Australia with certain areas highlighted
I

n Australia, all electrical and electronics devices, including cellular modules, need to comply with the requirements of the Regulatory Compliance Mark (RCM). The RCM is of two parts jointly owned by the Australian Communications Media Authority (ACMA) and the Electrical Regulatory Authorities Council (ERAC). Cellular approvals are technically complex and involve all aspects of the ACMA regulations and the ERAC Electrical Equipment Safety System (EESS) RCM certification process.

ACMA RCM Requirements
Most recently amended in 2018, the ACMA’s standard TLN: Telecommunications (Labelling Notice for Customer Equipment and Customer Cabling) Instrument 2015 mandates that cellular devices intended for connection to the public mobile telecommunications service (PMTS) must comply with Telecommunications (Mobile Equipment Air Interface) Technical Standard 2018, which in turn references AS/CA S042.1, Requirements for Connection to an Air Interface of a Telecommunications Network – Part 1: General.
Feature Article
Controlling Static Electricity: A 50-Year History
The recognition and control of static electricity today has benefitted from a continuously evolving approach
By David E. Swenson, John Kinnear, and the ESDA
A man holding a lightening bolt
I

t is well understood that static electricity has been with us forever. Our awareness of problems associated with static electricity probably originated with the invention of gun powder when, no doubt, there were some mysterious ignitions that took place during chemical blending operations that could not be explained at the time.

The manifestation of static electricity problems in an industrial setting likely began with Gutenberg’s invention of the automatic printing press in 1440.1 Paper and velum (two different materials) sticking together had to be an issue. Somewhere along the line, it was likely observed that a fire burning in the vicinity of the printing press could magically make the paper less sticky. Flame treatment was used in industrial printing presses back then and in newspaper printing presses well into the 1950s, and perhaps even longer in some areas.

Static control has been practiced in munitions, modern pyrotechnics, petroleum processing, and other industries dealing with explosive and flammable materials for a long time. The grounding of process tools, equipment, and personnel has been practiced since Ben Franklin’s time.

Reduce test time,
not accuracy
Every R&S®ESW comes with an FFT-based time domain scan capability. Measurements that took minutes or hours in sweep mode now take just seconds. The instrument combines the functions of an EMI test receiver and a full-featured spectrum analyzer in a single device.
KEY FACTS

► Frequency ranges 1 Hz to 8 GHz, 1 Hz to 26.5 GHz and 1 Hz to 44 GHz

► Compliant with CISPR16-1-1, ANSIC63.2, MIL STD 461 and FCC

► Highest dynamic range and highest accuracy for demanding certification measurement

Rohde & Schwarz logo
Rohde & Schwarz (RS) logo
Feature Article
Contact Burn Injuries
The Influence of Object Thermal Mass
By May Yen, Francesco Colella, Harri Kytomaa, Boyd Allin, and Alex Ockfen
Contact burn warning sign illustration
Editor’s Note: The paper on which this article is based was originally presented at the 2020 IEEE International Symposium on Product Safety Engineering held virtually in November 2020, where it received recognition as the Symposium’s Best Paper. It is reprinted here with the gracious permission of the IEEE. Copyright 2021 IEEE.

Part II of this paper, “The Influence of Object Shape, Size, Contact Resistance, and Applied Heat Flux”, is available through the IEEE Explore archives at http://www.ieeexplore.ieee.org.

T

he skin is made up of three distinct layers. The top layer of the skin that does not contain blood vessels and functions as the protective barrier of the skin is called the epidermis. The layer underneath the epidermis is called the dermis and contains blood vessels and nerve endings. Under the dermis is the subcutaneous fat also known as the hypodermis. Basal skin cells are located underneath the epidermis and are responsible for the generation of new tissue.

EMC concepts explained
Evaluation of EMC Emissions and Ground Techniques on 1- and 2-layer PCBs with Power Converters
Part 1: Top-Level Description of the Design Problem
By Bogdan Adamczyk, Scott Mee, and Nick Koeller
T

his is the first of a series of articles devoted to the design, test, and EMC emissions evaluation of 1- and 2-layer PCBs that contain AC/DC and/or DC/DC converters and employ different ground techniques. In this introductory article, we present a top-level block diagram description of the design problem under research. The subsequent articles will be devoted to the specific parts of the design, and subsequently to the RF emissions performance of the PCB assembly. This is a research in progress. The goal of this study is to evaluate the impact of different grounding strategies and the tradeoff with other design constraints that designers often face.

hot topics in ESD
WHAT EXACTLY IS ESD FOR 3D ICs?
By Harald Gossner for EOS/ESD Association, Inc.
F

or decades, Moore’s law has been driven by the downscaling of transistor dimensions on silicon. When reaching the ultra-advanced integrated circuit (IC) fabrication technologies in the single-digit nm regime (currently 5 nm CMOS is in volume ramp) there is little headroom left, and a different path of packing more functionality into an even smaller volume at the lowest power and cost has to be taken. 3D and 2.5D IC packaging technologies have become primary candidates to serve this purpose [1]. Both packaging technologies, which are often also referred to as ‘heterogenous integration’, have reached the maturity for volume production and can already be found in products.

A valid question to ask is what is 3D or even 2.5D packaging about? 3D packaging means to stack dies of silicon on top of each other and contact them in large numbers by die-to-die connections (see Figure 1). Today thousands of interconnects are running between a bottom die and a top die. This is predicted to grow into the tens of thousands to millions of interconnects per square millimeter of die area. One essential step in the process is to use so-called through silicon vias (TSVs) to route power and signals from the bottom side to the top side of a die. 2.5D packaging in contrast describes the assembly of silicon dies side-by-side atop an interposer substrate, which serves as a carrier on which the routing lines/connectivity between the dies are implemented (Figure 2).

330
VCR/CD/DVC combo TV sends out false distress signals

This October, Chris van Rossman of Corvallis Oregon turned on his do-everything combo TV and got a big surprise—the police, the Civil Air Patrol, and the County Search and Rescue Officers knocked on his door. Apparently, Mr. van Rossman’s flat screen, VCR/CD/DVC combo TV had developed some sort of strong emission (a parasitic oscillation, more than likely) at 121.5 MHz, which is a rescue frequency used by aircraft and boat distress transponders and monitored by orbiting satellites. This service uses an uncoded analog carrier detection system, and is therefore rather sensitive to unauthorized transmissions…

331
Illegal truck radio transmitters suspected of causing two bus accidents

It has been reported widely in the Japanese press that electromagnetic interference caused by illegally modified transceivers on trucks is suspected of causing two accidents by disabling the braking system of commuter buses. Mitsubishi Fuso Truck & Bus Corporation announced that two models of its buses are adversely affected by high-powered EMI from short distance and its braking system may not function properly under such conditions. Specifically, its braking system that detects the wheel-locking condition falsely triggers due to the EMI and thus the brake doesn’t work as intended…

press releases
PRESS Releases
Waveguide Components
double ridge waveguide components that are ideal for radar, wireless, and satellite communication devices
Fairview Microwave has launched its new line of double ridge waveguide components that are ideal for radar, wireless, and satellite communication devices, and for test instrumentation. The line includes 28 models in a variety of configurations and covering a wide range of frequency bands. Each offers superior RF performance and provides lower cut-off frequencies than comparable rectangular waveguides.

Fairview Microwave,
an Infinite Electronics brand
http://www.infiniteelectronics.com

Element Expands Product Qualification Testing Capabilities
 man performing a product qualification test
Element Materials Technology has expanded its product qualification testing (PQT) capabilities at its testing sites in Hull and Hitchin (UK) to address the broader range of wireless technology requirements. This expansion includes CB and UKAS accreditation to test to IEC 62368-1 and IEC 62368-3, which cover a variety of smart and connected technologies, such as tablets, routers, printers, and audio-visual equipment formerly covered under IEC 60950-1 and IEC 60065. The company’s Hull testing facility is also UKAS accredited for testing to IEC 17025, and is a Notified Body for the EU’s R&TTE Directive.

Element Materials Technology
http://www.element.com

Current-Compensated Ring Core Chokes
current-compensated EPSOC double-ring core chokes for the suppression of common-mode interferences
TDK Corporation offers a new series of current-compensated EPSOC double-ring core chokes for the suppression of common-mode interferences in switch-mode power supplies, converters, and domestic appliances. The chokes are available in three sizes with current handling capabilities between 10-17 A, and with a rated voltage of 250 V AC (50/60 Hz). The plastic material used in the ring core conforms with UL 94 V-0, and the components offer extremely small dimensions in relation to their current capacity.

TDK Corporation
http://www.tdk-electronics.tdk.com

EMI Prototype Shielding
shielding material for use in printed circuit board prototyping
Orbel has introduced its Groove-LocTM EMI shielding material for use in printed circuit board prototyping. The two-part system is comprised of a bendable, formable fence strip and a locking cover, and is made from a highly solderable nickel silver alloy that provides shielding from medium to high levels of electromagnetic interferences. The design and quick assembly of the Groove-Loc system provides an optimal solution for low to mid-volume production requirements.

Orbel
http://www.orbel.com

Source Measure Units for Specialty Power Supplies
test and measurement equipment with the addition of two new source measure units
Rohde & Schwarz has expanded its lineup of test and measurement equipment with the addition of two new source measure units (SMUs) to meet specialized power supply testing needs. The company’s new two-quadrant model NGU201 addresses wireless device battery tests and can switch from source mode to sink mode at a defined positive input voltage. The four-quadrant NGU 401 can conduct the same testing at both positive and negative voltages, supporting source measurements for a wide range of power supply types.

Rohde & Schwarz
http://www.rohde-schwarz.com

Isolation Tester for Shielded Enclosures
JRE TVK isolation tester, designed to help verify the proper shielding isolation of radiofrequency
Saelig has introduced its new JRE TVK isolation tester, designed to help verify the proper shielding isolation of radiofrequency (RF) enclosure test set-ups. The testing consists of a sensitive, handheld spectrum analyzer and a high power 2.45 GHz test signal source that can measure enclosure isolation down to less than -100dB. The isolation tester also requires no adjustment, eliminating complicated spectrum analyzer adjustment or erroneous readings.

Saelig Company, Inc.
http://www.saelig.com

Upcoming Events
May 11
Annual Chicago IEEE EMC MiniSymposium

May 11-14
Applying Practical EMI Design & Troubleshooting Techniques

May 13
EMC Fest 2021

May 17-20
IEEE International Instrumentation & Measurement Technology Conference

May 18-20
The Battery Show: Digital Days

May 19
EMC & Compliance International (EMCUK) 2021

June 6-11
International Microwave Symposium (IMS)

June 15-18
Applying Practical EMI Design & Troubleshooting Techniques

June 26
IEC International Special Committee on Radio Interference (CISPR)

June 28-30
Sensors Expo and Conference

Due to COVID-19 concerns, events may be postponed. Please check the event website for current information.
shielded enclosure in a anechoic chamber
A leading manufacturer in Shielded Enclosures & Anechoic Chambers
We design, engineer, and build quality turnkey anechoic solutions to meet your requirements and specifications.
In collaboration with Siepel, one of Europe’s leading designers and manufacturers of anechoic and reverberation systems, our solutions are guaranteed for quality and performance.
See how Raymond EMC can take your projects to the next level with our cutting-edge custom products and outstanding client service. Learn more and request pricing at raymondemc.com.
Raymond EMC provides clients with:
  • Anechoic and Reverb Chambers
  • RF Shielded Enclosures, including Deployable Solutions
  • Upgrades, repairs, maintenance, relocation, testing
  • Responsive service by our seasoned team of experts
Serving clients in North America & Internationally
1-800-EMC-1495
Follow us on
Facebook logo
Twitter logo
LinkedIn logo
raymond emc and siepel logo
In Compliance: The Compliance information Resource for Electrical Engineers logo
Thanks for reading our May 2021 issue!