In Compliance: The Compliance Information Resource for Electrical Engineers logo
Assessing Advanced Driver Assistance Systems in Vehicles
PLUS
Simulation-Based Testing for Early Safety Validation of Robot Systems

Expected Service Life of Medical Electrical Equipment

Foreseeability: A Critical Analysis in Minimizing Pre-Sale and Post‑Sale Liability

digital illustration of a car
PLUS
Simulation-Based Testing for Early Safety Validation of Robot Systems

Expected Service Life of Medical Electrical Equipment

Foreseeability: A Critical Analysis in Minimizing Pre-Sale and Post‑Sale Liability

November 2021
down arrow
Design for EMC
Live virtual Training Course
November 9 – 11, 2021
Learn Practical Tools, Tips, and Techniques for Bulletproof Designs
man working on laptop
This expert-led, live, multi-day virtual training focuses on common interference and signal problems faced by the designers of today’s high speed digital and mixed digital/analog circuits and systems and will teach participants how to identify, prevent, and fix common EMC design problems.
  • Learn to address Key EMI threats: Emissions, ESD, RFI, Power Disturbances & More
  • Focus on what is inside the box: Components, Printed Circuit Boards, Power Electronics, Grounding, and Shielding.
  • Includes over 35 Practical Design EMC Fixes!
  • Participate in interactive discussions and learn from realistic scenarios
  • Increase your skillset from the comfort of your home or office
  • Become more confident and efficient in your product design
  • Learn to address Key EMI threats: Emissions, ESD, RFI, Power Disturbances & More
  • Focus on what is inside the box: Components, Printed Circuit Boards, Power Electronics, Grounding, and Shielding.
  • Includes over 35 Practical Design EMC Fixes!
  • Participate in interactive discussions and learn from realistic scenarios
  • Increase your skillset from the comfort of your home or office
  • Become more confident and efficient in your product design
Daryl Gerke headshot
TAUGHT BY A RECOGNIZED AUTHORITY AND SPECIALIST IN THE FIELD.
Learn tools, tips and techniques from full time practitioner Daryl Gerke. PE, whose only business is solving and preventing EMC and related signal integrity problems. He has prevented or solved hundreds of EMI problems for clients in a wide range of industries. He has co-authored three books on EMC and over 200 technical articles.
Presented by EMI Guru
in partnership with
In Compliance logo
November 2021
Volume 13 l Number 11
Contents
By Ralph Buckingham
As they become more commonplace in today’s motor vehicles, advanced driver assist systems (ADAS) require a unique set of testing procedures that include repeatability of the trigger mechanism in a safe, controlled environment to accurately measure their effectiveness.
By Tom P. Huck, Christoph Ledermann, and Torsten Kröger
Industrial human-robot collaborative systems must be validated thoroughly with regard to safety. Due to the complexity of robot systems, safety flaws often stay hidden, especially at early design stages, when a physical implementation is not yet available for testing. Simulation-based testing is a possible way to identify hazards in an early stage.
By Steli Loznen
The definition of “expected service life” included in IEC 60601-1 standard potentially generates confusion and misinterpretation. This article provides an analysis of the “real-life” implications of this definition and proposes some clarifications.
By Kenneth Ross
This article will discuss the law of misuse and some ways in which manufacturers can practically perform a risk assessment, including an analysis of product misuse.
car steering wheel
hand reaching for robotic arm
technology in a recycling bin
woman working at computer
In Compliance logo
In Compliance Magazine
ISSN 1948-8254 (print)
ISSN 1948-8262 (online)
is published by

Same Page Publishing Inc.
451 King Street, #458
Littleton, MA 01460
tel: (978) 486-4684
fax: (978) 486-4691

©Copyright 2021 Same Page Publishing, Inc. all rights reserved

Contents may not be reproduced in any form without the prior consent of the publisher.
While every attempt is made to provide accurate information, neither the publisher nor the authors accept any liability for errors or omissions.

editor/
publisher
Lorie Nichols
lorie.nichols@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7777
business development director
Sharon Smith
sharon.smith@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7722
production director
Erin C. Feeney
erin.feeney@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7756
marketing director
Ashleigh O’Connor
ashleigh.oconnor@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7788
circulation director
Alexis Evangelous
alexis.evangelous@incompliancemag.com
(978) 486-4684
features editor
William von Achen
bill.vonachen@incompliancemag.com
(978) 486-4684
senior contributors
Bruce Archambeault
bruce@brucearch.com
Leonard Eisner
Leo@EisnerSafety.com
Daryl Gerke
dgerke@emiguru.com
columns contributors
EMC Concepts Explained
Bogdan Adamczyk
adamczyb@gvsu.edu
Hot Topics in ESD
EOS/ESD Association, Inc
info@esda.org
advertising
For information about advertising contact Sharon Smith at sharon.smith@incompliancemag.com.
subscriptions
In Compliance Magazine subscriptions are free to qualified subscribers in North America.
Subscriptions outside North America are $129 for 12 issues. The digital edition is free.
Please contact our circulation department at circulation@incompliancemag.com
compliance news
FDA Publishes List of Approved AI/ML-Enabled Medical Devices
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has published its first list of authorized medical devices incorporating software based on artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) technologies.

Posted to its website, the FDA’s list of AI/ML-enabled medical devices provides detailed submission information on nearly 350 separate medical devices that have been reviewed and authorized by the agency under its 510(k), De Novo, or PMA routes…

UK Seeks Overhaul of AI, Software as a Medical Device
In the wake of its exit from the European Union, the United Kingdom is working to update regulations applicable to medical devices that use software based on artificial intelligence (AI).

The UK’s Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency detailed its plans in a recently released Guidance, “Software and AI as a Medical Device Change Programme.” The Guidance maps out 11 different “work packages” that would implement changes across the entire medical device lifecycle, from initial product qualification to post-market surveillance…

Dilbert Comic
DILBERT © 2021 Scott Adams. Used By permission of ANDREWS MCMEEL SYNDICATION. All rights reserved.
Feature Article
Assessing Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS) in Vehicles
Testing Can Help to Ensure Effectiveness and Safety
By Ralph Buckingham
Driving Wheel
T

he National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) estimates that 94% of traffic accidents are caused by driver error and the leading cause of these is recognition mistakes.1 Advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS) can help decrease accidents, injuries, and fatalities by reducing these errors using electronic technologies. In fact, ADAS is one of the fastest-growing sectors in the automotive industry, with expectations that the ADAS market will see a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 11.6% by 2027.2

ADAS are designed to increase the safety of vehicles by assisting motorists with driving and parking functions. They use automated technology, such as sensors, cameras, software, lighting, and audio components to detect obstacles and errors, then respond accordingly. ADAS technologies can range from passive to active, alerting drivers to problems, implementing safeguards, and/or taking control of the vehicle.

Passive systems simply give an alert but require the driver to act. Examples might be systems that make noises or vibrate when an object, such as another vehicle or pedestrian, is sensed in a blind spot or as the car drifts into another lane without a turn signal activated. With the warning, the driver needs to take corrective action. On the other hand, active ADAS not only sense the danger, but also automatically activate the required corrective action, such as emergency braking when an obstruction is sensed.

ETS-Lindgren
BEYOND MEASURE.™
ETS Lindgen logo

BONUS CONTENT
ETS-Lindgren Model 2304 Precision Multi-Axis
Positioning System (MAPS) Demo

BONUS CONTENT
ETS-Lindgren Model 2304 Precision Multi-Axis Positioning System (MAPS) Demo

Visit us, follow us, watch us, and connect with us at:

Facebook logoTwitter logoYoutube logoLinkedin logo

Visit us, follow us, watch us, and connect with us at:

Facebook logoTwitter logoYoutube logoLinkedin logo

ETS-Lidgren's Wireless Testing Solutions Video - Play
MEET 5G TESTING CHALLENGES WITH CONFIDENCE.
The new 5G technologies challenge EMC test systems to push the limits of measurements up to 200 and 300 GHz. ETS-Lindgren, an expert in both the EMC and wireless testing methodologies, understands the new demands of 5G technologies and how the traditional EMC test methods and procedures are breaking down as the measurements push into the mmWave spectrum. ETS-Lindgren is your trusted advisor to meet the challenges of 5G mmWave Emissions Measurements with confidence.

For more information on our 5G solutions, visit our website at www.ets-lindgren.com.

Feature Article
Simulation-Based Testing for Early Safety Validation of Robot Systems
By Tom P. Huck, Christoph Ledermann, and Torsten Kröger
Simulation-Based Testing for Early Safety Validation of Robot Systems

Editor’s Note: The paper on which this article is based was originally presented at the 2020 IEEE International Symposium on Product Safety Engineering held virtually in November 2020. It is reprinted here with the gracious permission of the IEEE. Copyright 2020 IEEE.

I

ndustrial human-robot collaboration (HRC) promises a more flexible production and more direct support for human workers [1]. In HRC applications, human and robot work in close vicinity or even in direct collaboration. Safety fences, which have traditionally been used to ensure the safety of human workers, are (at least partially) absent. Instead, sensor- and software-based safety measures, such as laser scanners, light curtains, velocity limitation, and collision detection, are used to ensure that the robot system does not pose any hazard to human workers. Safety flaws in the configuration of these safety measures can lead to hazards. Thus, a thorough safety validation is required. Furthermore, ISO 10218‑2, the safety standard for industrial robot systems, specifically states that prior to commissioning, a risk assessment must be conducted to identify and assess potential hazards [2].

Testing and Product Approvals for Global Markets
Speech bubble saying I prefer my tests shaken AND stirred
Washington Laboratories, Ltd. logo
Speech bubble saying I prefer my tests shaken AND stirred
Washington Laboratories, Ltd. logo
Speech bubble saying I prefer my tests shaken AND stirred
robot sitting on the couch drinking a martini
Washington Laboratories, Ltd. logo
EMC/Wireless – Environmental – Product Safety
Washington Laboratories, Ltd. | 301-216-1500 | www.wll.com | info@wll.com
Washington Laboratories, Ltd.

301-216-1500

www.wll.com

info@wll.com
Feature Article
Expected Service Life of Medical Electrical Equipment
Clarifying Confusion Around “Life” Definitions
By Steli Loznen
heart monitor in green recycle bin
T

he main purpose of mandatory regulations is to obtain marketing authorization to enter global markets. Consequently, a manufacturer must demonstrate that all safety-related aspects, including compliance with relevant standards for basic safety, essential performance, risk management, usability, etc., have been reviewed, that all applicable requirements have been met, and that a quality system mechanism has been implemented.

With regard to medical devices included within the field of the medical electrical equipment (MEE), it is striking to observe how the clauses describing these specific concepts vary among applicable EU Directives, guidelines, regulations, IEC, ISO standards, and other requirements applicable to design, regulatory compliance, marketing, and health professionals.

Moreover, the concept of “expected service life” (ESL) for MEE comes on top of the already existing standards. Thus, due to an incomplete definition of ESL, there is a long chain of misunderstandings regarding the analysis and assessment required to determine compliance with MEE requirements.

Feature Article
Foreseeability: A Critical Analysis in Minimizing Pre-Sale and Post‑Sale Liability
When Is Misuse Reasonably Foreseeable?
By Kenneth Ross
Lady getting work done on laptop while having scattered papers on her desk
T

he law requires manufacturers to anticipate foreseeable uses and risks when designing products and providing warnings and instructions. In addition to foreseeable uses, manufacturers must also predict future conduct by users and consider what conduct constitutes foreseeable misuse.

But how far must a manufacturer go to anticipate unintended but foreseeable misuses of a product? How does a manufacturer make this determination while designing the product? What do courts regard as a foreseeable misuse, and what must a manufacturer do about it? Does an unforeseeable misuse become a foreseeable misuse if, after a product’s sale, it comes to light that some people have actually misused the product?

These questions go to the core of a manufacturer’s quest to provide a reasonably safe product before and after a sale. Unfortunately, the answers are unclear and, in most situations, are provided by a judge and jury after a trial.

EMC concepts explained
Evaluation of EMC Emissions and Ground Techniques on 1- and 2-layer PCBs with Power Converters
Part 6: PCB Layout Considerations
By Bogdan Adamczyk, Scott Mee, and Nick Koeller
I

n this article, we discuss the PCB layout considerations and the design of the reference return paths for the one- and two-layer boards.

1. Introduction
The PCB layout and the design of reference return connections (may also be referred to as grounding) play a critical role in the EMC performance of any circuit. This is especially critical for power converters, which are the focus of this series of articles. In circuit design, it can be easy to focus on power and signal trace connections while overlooking or not focusing enough attention on how circuit current returns. Proper reference return design can especially be challenging in single- and two-layer designs where best practices can’t always be applied. It is important to understand and visualize the path of the return current so its entire loop area can be controlled by design. The complete loop area of each circuit tends to be the dominant factor when compared with other parasitic inductances associated with the components or vias. This inductance has a detrimental effect on the EMC performance.
hot topics in ESD
Understanding Footwear and Flooring in ESD Control
By Dr. Jeremy Smallwood for EOS/ESD Association, Inc.
I have a floor that complies with IEC 61340-5-1 and ANSI/ESD S20.20, and buy footwear that also complies, so that’s sorted then?

Well, not really. It’s a good starting point, but you need to know that the flooring and footwear work together. Unfortunately, I’ve seen cases where they don’t. If that happens, you’re fooling yourself if you think you’ve got human body ESD risk under control. I’ve seen a person wearing footwear that measures about 10 MΩ, standing on a floor that measures about 10 MΩ, but their resistance from body to ground was over 1 GΩ, and a body voltage test while walking showed well over 100 V.

Hang on – how can that be? If the footwear and flooring were both about 10 MΩ, surely the resistance from body to ground should have been about 20 MΩ?

In an ideal world, you might think so – but there’s another factor – contact resistance between the footwear and the floor.

354
Marine mains supply harmonic distortion problems solved

The Ocean Challenger is a very high bollard pull cableship of UT746C dual role design, equipped with a Rockplough that allows for simultaneous cable lay and burial to 1.0m depth in fractured rock, 2.2m in sand/clays and 3.0m in soft soils. The Ocean Challenger’s trenching operation is performed by a 2MW Remotely Operated Pipe-line Trenching Vehicle…

355
Piezo gas lighter controls tape player

In the kitchen we have a radio/tape/cd and recently the tapes have been playing with very poor sound quality. No amount of head cleaning has improved the sound. By chance we found that operating the piezo gun to light the gas hob fixes the problem. Must be switching some ‘hiss’ correction circuit for which there is no external control, button switch etc…

356
Radar dome suspected of interfering with car immobilisers and lights

Reports that a radar dome in Norfolk is causing electrical problems with cars are being investigated by the Ministry of Defence (MoD). Motorists say their engines and lights have cut out, and their speedometer dials swing up to 150mph as they drive past the Trimingham radar unit…

357
Cellphones can interfere more strongly with aircraft navigation than previously believed

A study by Carnegie Mellon University researchers in the Department of Engineering and Public Policy (EPP) has found that cell phones and other portable electronic devices, like laptops and game-playing devices, can pose dangers to the normal operation of critical electronics on airplanes. The study will be featured in an article appearing in the March issue of IEEE Spectrum…

Upcoming Events
2021
November 9-11
Design for EMC

November 9-11
Fundamentals of Random Vibration and Shock Testing

November 17-18
The Battery Show Digital Days

November 30 – December 2
The Battery Show Europe

2022
February 15-17
European Microwave Week

March 8-11
EMC Compo

May 8-11
APEMC

May 18-19
EMC & Compliance International Worskshop

August 1-5
EMC+SIPI

September 5-8
EMC Europe

Due to COVID-19 concerns, events may be postponed. Please check the event website for current information.
In Compliance: The Compliance information Resource for Electrical Engineers logo
Thanks for reading our November 2021 issue!