In Compliance logo
The Compliance Information Resource for Electrical Engineers
A Brief History of
ESD Testing of Electronic Products
PLUS
Automotive High-Speed Interfaces: Future Challenges for System-Level HV ESD Protection and First-Time-Right Design

(Re)Discovering the Lost Science of Near-Field Measurements, Part 3

Special Coverage:
EOS/ESD Symposium Preview

PLUS
Automotive High-Speed Interfaces: Future Challenges for System-Level HV ESD Protection and First-Time-Right Design

(Re)Discovering the Lost Science of Near-Field Measurements, Part 3

Special Coverage:
EOS/ESD Symposium Preview

September 2023
AR
This is How You Reduce
Testing Time by More Than 50%
With regulatory adoption of multiple signal radiated immunity test methods (IEC-61000-4-3:2020, 4th edition), AR’s Multi-Tone System enables you to vastly reduce your test times in accordance with automotive, commercial, and aviation EMC RI standards. Included is AR’s proprietary emcware® software, offering users numerous test and calibration routines utilizing multiple signal methodology, to meet these standards.

For example, AR’s Multi-Tone System can reduce the typical time to run traditional tests such as IEC 61000-4-3, ISO 11451, and ISO 11452, by over 50%. In the event of an EUT failure, margin investigation and traditional single tone testing is easily performed through AR’s emcware® software.

Graph
Multiple full sweeps are often required during mitigation efforts, which is where the multiple signal approach will pay dividends.

This is a creative way to help your company be more profitable by using your assets more efficiently.

Visit us at www.arworld.us or call 215-723-8181.
Talk to an applications engineer at 800.933.8181.
AR logo
AR logo
AR logo
We’re with you all the way
ar rf/microwave instrumentation - ar modular rf - sunar - ar europe
In Compliance logo
In Compliance Magazine
ISSN 1948-8254 (print)
ISSN 1948-8262 (online)
is published by

Same Page Publishing Inc.
451 King Street, #458
Littleton, MA 01460
tel: (978) 486-4684
fax: (978) 486-4691

©Copyright 2023 Same Page Publishing, Inc. all rights reserved

Contents may not be reproduced in any form without the prior consent of the publisher.
While every attempt is made to provide accurate information, neither the publisher nor the authors accept any liability for errors or omissions.

editor/
publisher
Lorie Nichols
lorie.nichols@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7777

business development director
Sharon Smith
sharon.smith@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7722

production director
Erin C. Feeney
erin.feeney@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7756

marketing director
Ashleigh O’Connor
ashleigh.oconnor@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7788

circulation director
Alexis Evangelous
alexis.evangelous@incompliancemag.com
(978) 486-4684

features editor
William von Achen
bill.vonachen@incompliancemag.com
(978) 486-4684

senior contributors
Bruce Archambeault
bruce@brucearch.com
Leonard Eisner
Leo@EisnerSafety.com
Daryl Gerke
dgerke@emiguru.com

columns contributors
EMC Concepts Explained
Bogdan Adamczyk
adamczyb@gvsu.edu

Hot Topics in ESD
EOS/ESD Association, Inc
info@esda.org

advertising
For information about advertising contact Sharon Smith at sharon.smith@incompliancemag.com.

subscriptions
In Compliance Magazine subscriptions are free to qualified subscribers in North America. Subscriptions outside North America are $129 for 12 issues. The digital edition is free. Please contact our circulation department at circulation@incompliancemag.com

September 2023
Volume 15 l Number 9
Contents
By Daniel D. Hoolihan
This updated version of an article originally published in the March 2014 issue provides details on recent and current developments in the ESD testing of electronic products.
By Sergej Bub, Markus Mergens, Andreas Hardock, Steffen Holland, and Ayk Hilbrink
This paper describes future design challenges of discrete system-level ESD protection (high-voltage, low-capacitance) of automotive high-speed data links such as multi-gigabit ETHERNET and SERDES/video-links. A special focus is put on an in-depth analysis and accurate modeling of the complex ESD behavior of the Common Mode Choke (CMC).
A preview of the Symposium taking place in Riverside, CA from September 30 through October 5, 2023.
By Ken Javor
This article is the third in a series commemorating 70 years since the advent of modern EMI testing. But this last article is itself divided into multiple parts, due to the topic’s complexity. Unlike the previous two articles, which mainly tracked evolution and explained issues, this series of installments argues that we started off correctly seventy years ago, but then took the wrong fork in the road in 1967.
hand holding lightning in a bottle
point of view from the back middle seat of a car
aerial view of Riverside, CA
digital illustration of a person looking off the edge of a cliff
compliance news
FCC Proposes More Power Flexibility for FM Stations
The U.S. Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is taking steps to provide certain FM radio stations with more flexibility to increase digital power levels for their operations.

The Commission’s Order and Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) proposes to change the way FM stations determine their maximum permissible power level and, further, to give FM stations the authority to operate their digital sidebands at different power levels. According to the FCC…

FCC Proposes $20 Million Penalty for Failing to Protect Consumer Data
The U.S. Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has proposed a $20 million fine against two affiliated wireless companies for failing to adequately secure and protect the personal data of subscribers.

According to a Notice of Apparent Liability for Forfeiture, the companies, Q Link Wireless LLC, and Hello Mobile Telecom LLC, routinely relied on…

Feature Article
A Brief History of Electrostatic Discharge (ESD) Testing of Electronic Products
Revisited and Revised as of 2023
By Daniel D. Hoolihan
a clear glass cork top bottle with blue lightning inside
W

ith the inventions of the transistor in 1947 and the integrated circuit in 1958, and the utilization of these major solid-state breakthroughs in the development of computers and other electronic devices, industry began to worry about designing components and end-products that could survive the impact of electrostatic discharges to chips, printed circuit boards, and final packaged-products. The 1960s and 1970s saw individual companies developing their own ESD test values and laboratory test techniques. The International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC), which is closely related to the International Standards Organization (ISO), got involved in the 1980s with the release of IEC 801-2 in 1984 on ESD limits and susceptibility test methods. Since the late 1980s, most electronic companies test their end-products for ESD immunity in accordance with the specifications found in IEC 801-2 and its follow-on standard, IEC 61000-4-2.

In the Beginning
The electrostatic discharge (ESD) phenomena have been known since the Greek civilization was dominant thousands of years ago. Experiments with glass rods and cloth material produced ESD sparks. And people in colder climates were very familiar with the ESD effect due to a low-relative humidity environment inside a building or house. They frequently experienced an ESD event as they walked across a carpet in the winter season.

Exodus

Above
the Rest
…providing
industry firsts
with our frequency
& power capabilities
three quarter view of the AMP4066A-1LC, 26,5-40GHz, 100W
AMP4066A-1LC, 26.5-40GHz, 100W
Exodus provides “Industry Firsts” covering these frequency ranges in all SSPA:

1.0-18.0GHz, 100W, 200W, 300W, 500W…
1.0-40.0GHz, as well and for the 18.0-40.0GHz range 40W, 100W, 200W

No other company
can do this anywhere!!!
Exodus Advanced Communications logo
3674 E. Sunset Road, Suite 100, Las Vegas, Nevada 89120
702-534-6564 • www.exoduscomm.comsales@exoduscomm.com
Feature Article
Automotive High-Speed Interfaces:
Future Challenges for System-Level HV ESD Protection and First-Time-Right Design
By Sergej Bub, Markus Mergens, Andreas Hardock, Steffen Holland, and Ayk Hilbrink
internal view of a car with holographic interfaces on the steering wheel, front windshield and dashboard center console

Editor’s Note: The paper on which this article is based was originally presented at the 43rd Annual EOS/ESD Symposium in October 2021. It was subsequently awarded the 2021 Symposium Outstanding Paper at the 44th Annual EOS/ESD Symposium in September 2022. It is reprinted here with the gracious permission of the EOS/ESD Association, Inc.

Introduction

The automotive industry is experiencing a revolutionary transformation towards electrification, autonomous driving, as well as more connectivity and information. Thus, in-vehicle-network architecture is changing with an exploding amount of data cars need to process at high-speed. For example, infotainment content is rapidly increasing with an average of 20 cameras and 15 displays per vehicle. In addition, the new zonal architecture requires a new IP based protocol. Here, the automotive ethernet plays a key role for the links with data rates up to 1 Gbit/s today and multi-Gbit/s in the future. The so-called Open Alliance Committee defines a standard for those links in EHTERNET 100/1000BASE-T1, especially for the ESD protection device [1].

Why An ESD Flooring System?
A flooring installation is only as strong as its weakest component. It could be floor prep or installation. The haphazard use of ESD footwear. Or incompatible seating.

Any of these factors can compromise the integrity of your ESD-control program.

For optimal results, think of ESD flooring as an interdependent system. Of compatible, ANSI-certified parts.

StaticWorx GroundSafe ESD Flooring logo
Call us: 617-923-2000
Visit us: staticworx.com
Groundsafe ESD flooring in factory
rolling chair with floor underneath and meter attached
StaticWorx Bolt ESD Chair
digital illustration of factory safe shoe
EOS/ESD Symposium Preview
September 30 – October 5, 2023
clipart of a lightning bolt
Join us in person at the 2023 EOS/ESD Symposium
aerial view of Riverside, CA
T

he last three EOS/ESD Symposiums were offered in a hybrid format for presenters and attendees – facilitating virtual connection for those strongly impacted by pandemic-related travel restrictions. In 2022, more than 200 attendees and 36 exhibiting companies traveled to the Peppermill in Reno, NV, USA, and only 50 attendees participated virtually. The shift of attendees attending virtually in 2020 and 2021 to in-person in 2022 demonstrates the value and importance of face-to-face events and activities.

After considering many variables influencing a decision to host face-to-face-only events, the EOS/ESD Symposium will be on-site with no livestream connection in 2023. This decision means the Symposium strategy team can explore new ways to increase the interactivity that attendees truly value – the face-to-face and networking opportunities provided by an in-person event.

These opportunities include enhancing already established interactive sessions, such as workshops and hands-on demonstrations, and adding new initiatives. One focus is revamping the format of workshops with a task team already evaluating innovative solutions, such as interactive polling, a panel of invited speakers, and a new standalone session on the upcoming revision to the EOS/ESD Association, Inc. Technology Roadmap. We are introducing a new interactive session with members of the Association’s standards working group activities and a new exciting electronic format for the Author’s Corner posters. Other exciting ideas include expanding the exhibit hall offerings with introductory tours to meet the exhibitors and demonstrations by exhibitors in their booths.

We appreciate your understanding and trust that EOS/ESD Association, Inc. has carefully considered the many impacts of hosting an in-person-only Symposium in 2023. With your support, EOS/ESD Symposium will continue to be the premier industry event. The 2023 Symposium Strategy and Steering Teams are excited about what’s to come, and we hope you are as well!

We look forward to seeing you in person at the 2023 EOS/ESD Symposium at the Riverside Convention Center in Riverside, CA, USA

Electrostatic Discharge Association
Setting the Global Standards for Static Control
Exhibits/Show Stoppers
September 30 – October 5, 2023
clipart of a lightning bolt
StaticStop by SelecTech
Booth 110/112

Come visit us at Booth 110/112 and see the most complete line of Static Control Flooring options available. We have resinous floor coatings, several glue-down options, interlocking options, carpet, rubber, all the maintenance products to keep your floor looking great and providing continuous static control. We are the market leader in Static Control Flooring and have been experts in the field for more than 20 years. Because we have such a complete line, we can help you choose the right product for your application. Visit us in Booth 110/112 or at https://staticstop.com.

StaticWorx
Booth 114

An ESD flooring installation is only as good as its weakest component. Visit us at Booth 114 and learn why it’s crucial to think of ESD flooring as a system, not a standalone product. Learn why it’s critical to evaluate and specify flooring, furniture, chairs, casters and carts as an interdependent package that should be prequalified to ANSI acceptance standards. And why considering flooring as part of a system makes the most of your investment, ensuring the success of your ESD flooring installation. StaticWorx. We keep you grounded. Visit us in Booth 114 or call (617) 923-2000.

Feature Article
(Re)Discovering the Lost Science of Near-Field Measurements, Part 3
Understanding Radiated Emissions Measurements Made at One-Meter Separation: It’s Not What You’ve Been Led to Believe
By Ken Javor
Stylized vector drawing of hiker looking out over cliff edge
T

his is the third part of our article “(Re)Discovering the Lost Science of Near Field Measurements.” Part 1 of this article (see In Compliance Magazine, July 2023) explained what near and far field measurements entail, and that one-meter measurements are very much near field. Part 2 (In Compliance Magazine, August 2023) explained the evolution of the earlier 12” and present-day one-meter separation measurements, considerations in antenna selection, the difference between antenna-induced and field strength limits, and the evolution from one to the other. This third part investigates practical problems arising from the misapplication of field intensity and far-field concepts to near-field phenomena.

Practical Problems Arising from the Use of Field Intensity Limits in the Extreme Near Field23
The term “extreme near field” has a specific quantitative meaning in this context. It means that the transmit-receive antenna separation is of the same magnitude as its physical aperture, or less. In the case of radiated emission measurements made one meter away from a test sample with 1.5 m or longer attached cables, not even the Hertzian dipole equations suffice to describe the near field. The Hertzian dipole field equations only apply when the separation distance is much larger than the radiating structure dimensions.24
Feature Article
Journey to the Center of the Dipole
Being an Account of Explorations Into an EMC-Forbidden Zone
By Ken Javor
illustration of the center core of earth
The electrical engineering sub-discipline of electromagnetic compatibility has been described as the study of second-order effects that were ignored in college. Investigating electromagnetic fields next to a dipole is one such topic. Don’t cite Hertz and his dipole – he didn’t go there.
Introduction
This short article provides mathematical background for the longer “(Re)Discovering The Lost Science of Near Field Measurements” article presently serialized in this magazine.

This brief, lightly mathematical treatment demonstrates the true nature of the quasi-static electric and magnetic fields in the immediate vicinity of an excited dipole. The results are quite different than those presented in electromagnetics texts and electromagnetic compatibility handbooks.

EMC concepts explained
Return-Current Distribution in a PCB Microstrip Line Configuration
Part 2: Reference Plane with Discontinuities
By Bogdan Adamczyk and Scott Mee
T

his is the second article of a two-article series devoted to the return current distribution in a PCB microstrip line configuration. The previous article [1] presented the CST simulation results in the case of a solid reference plane. This article addresses the case where the reference plane contains several discontinuities: edge slot, internal slot, slot holes, and via cutouts.

1. Baseline Results
In [1], we presented the baseline results for a solid reference plane and showed the return current path (forward current trace is hidden) flowing in the reference plane at different frequencies.

The results showed that at 10 Hz the return current spreads wide over the reference plane, flowing both under the top trace and directly from the load port to the source port. As the frequency increases to 100 Hz, more of the return current flows under the trace (with a narrower spread), and less of it flows directly from the load port to the source port. This trend continues as the frequency increases to 1 kHz. As the frequency increases beyond 10kHz, the return current path remains virtually unchanged, predominantly flowing beneath the forward trace. In other words, the return current path and current density no longer depend on frequency.

hot topics in ESD
Can Electrostatic Discharge Design Problems Be Solved with Electronic Design Automation Tools Alone?
Part 2: What are the limitations of EDA tools?
By Michael Khazhinsky, Eleonora Gevinti, Krzysztof Domanski, Guido Quax, and Matthew Hogan for EOS/ESD Association, Inc.
I

n Part 1 of the article, we reviewed what EDA tools are good for. Here we will discuss EDA tool limitations.

A complete ESD solution is never made by EDA tools alone. Certain ESD design aspects are so specific for a product that it does not pay to make an EDA code for it (although it could fundamentally be done).

ESD is a complex phenomenon and ESD design verification involves checking a wide range of initial conditions and requirements (e.g., available area, stress tests validations conditions, single or cumulative stresses, special bonding or package conditions, external metallization levels, etc.). These require special inputs and appropriate initializations in EDA tools which often prevents ESD EDA from being a push-button solution. ESD protection strategies vary, and an EDA tool cannot always establish a priori the best strategy out of several existing ones.

Upcoming Events
September 4-8
EMC Europe

September 12-14
The Battery Show

September 17-22
European Microwave Week

September 21
2023 Minnesota EMC Event

September 26-29
Applying Practical EMI Design & Troubleshooting Techniques

Advanced Printed Circuit Board Design for EMC + SI

Mechanical Design for EMC

September 27
EMC/EMI Summit

October 1-6
45th EOS/ESD Symposium and Exhibits

October 3-6
Applying Practical EMI Design & Troubleshooting Techniques

Advanced Printed Circuit Board Design for EMC + SI

Mechanical Design for EMC

October 4-6
The Battery Show India

October 8-13
45th Annual Meeting and Symposium of the Antenna Measurement Techniques Association (AMTA)

October 17-20
Applying Practical EMI Design & Troubleshooting Techniques

Advanced Printed Circuit Board Design for EMC + SI

Mechanical Design for EMC

November 7-9
Fundamentals of Random Vibration and Shock Testing Training

Always check the event website for current information.
In Compliance: The Compliance information Resource for Electrical Engineers logo
Thanks for reading our September 2023 issue!