In Compliance: The Compliance Information Resource for Electrical Engineers logo
EMI Shielding and Thermal Interface Solutions
for Commercial and Defense Drone Technology
PLUS
Navigating Mexico Electrical Safety Certification Requirements

Circuit Spacings: Determining Product Safety Requirements

Preventing Liability from Foreign‑Made Products

digital skeleton of an airplane
PLUS
Navigating Mexico Electrical Safety Certification Requirements

Circuit Spacings: Determining Product Safety Requirements

Preventing Liability from Foreign‑Made Products

November 2024
AR Ametek logo
A Kilowatt On Your Desk
More Compact Power Than
Ever Thought Possible
The 800W1000 is designed to generate 200 V/m from 80 MHz – 1 GHz with a single phase input voltage.
For more information on AR Amplifiers, visit www.arworld.us

Or contact us at info@arworld.us & 215.723.8181

AR 800W1000 machine
In Compliance logo
In Compliance Magazine
ISSN 1948-8254 (print)
ISSN 1948-8262 (online)
is published by

Same Page Publishing Inc.
451 King Street, #458
Littleton, MA 01460
tel: (978) 486-4684
fax: (978) 486-4691

© Copyright 2024 Same Page Publishing, Inc. all rights reserved

Contents may not be reproduced in any form without the prior consent of the publisher. While every attempt is made to provide accurate information, neither the publisher nor the authors accept any liability for errors or omissions.

publisher/
editor-in-chief
Lorie Nichols
lorie.nichols@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7777
business development director
Sharon Smith
sharon.smith@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7722
production director
Erin C. Feeney
erin.feeney@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7756
marketing director
Ashleigh O’Connor
ashleigh.oconnor@incompliancemag.com
(978) 873-7788
circulation director
Alexis Evangelous
alexis.evangelous@incompliancemag.com
(978) 486-4684
features editor
William von Achen
bill.vonachen@incompliancemag.com
(978) 486-4684
senior contributors
Keith Armstrong
Ken Javor
Kenneth Ross
Min Zhang
columns contributors
Bogdan Adamczyk
Erin Earley
Min Zhang
EOS/ESD Association, Inc.
advertising
For information about advertising, contact Sharon Smith at sharon.smith@incompliancemag.com.
subscriptions
In Compliance Magazine subscriptions are free to qualified subscribers in North America. Subscriptions outside North America are $149 for 12 issues. The digital edition is free.

Please contact our circulation department at circulation@incompliancemag.com

November 2024
Volume 16 l Number 11
Contents
Columns
By Bogdan Adamczyk
By Wei Liang and Ahmed Ginawi for EOS/ESD Association, Inc.
By Keith Armstrong
Departments
compliance news
FCC to Require Georouting of 988 Calls to Speed Service Response
The U.S. Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is expected to vote on rules that would require U.S. wireless carriers to implement technology that would speed localized response to 988-related emergencies.

The nationwide 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline provides those dealing with severe mental health issues with fast access to trained professionals who can help them quickly access needed support and services. However, until now, emergency calls made from cell phones have been routed to emergency service providers based on the area code of the phone number assigned to the phone…

FCC Issues Harmful Radio Interference Notification
A Massachusetts person has received notice from the Enforcement Bureau of the U.S. Federal Communications Commission (FCC) to cease radio transmissions that were found to be interfering with a critical public safety communications system.

According to a Notification of Harmful Interference, a condominium on Worcester Road (known to locals as Route 9) was identified as the location from which radio emissions in the 813-817 MHz band originated. The emissions were linked to recent incidences of interference with the Massachusetts State Police public safety communications system…

Upcoming Events
November 5-7
XIV Electromagnetic Compatibility Course

November 15
IoT Applications

November 20-22
Battery Japan

December 3-5
Fundamentals of Random Vibration and Shock Testing Training

Thank you to our Premium Digital Partners
A.H. Systems logo
Element logo
Würth Elektronik logo
expert insights
EMC BENCH NOTES
How to Use Spectrum Analyzers for EMC
By Kenneth Wyatt
A

spectrum analyzer measures power (default) or voltage versus frequency. Most digital harmonic emissions occur in the range 10 kHz to 1 GHz and this defines the minimum frequency range for spectrum analyzers. Some harmonics may even extend up to 3 GHz. Two types of harmonic emissions will be observed: narrowband and broadband. Many times, you’ll see a combination of the two.

Narrowband Versus Broadband
Narrowband harmonics are the most common for radiated emissions and most likely to exceed the limits. They appear as a range of narrow spikes and are usually harmonically related (multiples of a clock frequency). For example, Ethernet is usually clocked at 25 MHz, so it’s common to see harmonics every 25 MHz, sometimes exceeding 1 GHz. Figure 1 shows a series of 25 MHz clock harmonics (aqua trace). The yellow trace is the measurement noise floor.
expert insights
PRACTICAL ENGINEERING
Pre-compliance for Product Safety
By Don MacArthur
E

MC Pre‑compliance Testing

Many articles, entire books, and chapters of books promote the benefits of performing pre-compliance electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) testing and show how easy it is to carry out bench-top EMC measurements using relatively inexpensive and homemade test apparatus.

EMC pre-compliance testing is highly beneficial. I strongly encourage doing it if you are interested in discovering EMC-related weaknesses in your design as early in the product development cycle as possible. Discovering EMC design weakness early means more and less costly solutions are available before the final design is locked down. So, the question is this: If pre-compliance activities are good for discovering EMC design weaknesses early in product development, why not apply the same thought process to product safety?

expert insights
Military and Aerospace EMC
Portable Electronics Onboard Aircraft
Part 1
By Patrick André
S

everal times, I have talked with people in the general public about the use of electronics on aircraft, often with the same response: “There is no good reason they have us turn off our electronics.” However, those of us in the EMC industry, and especially those in the aerospace aspect of the industry, know how true the issues can be. June 8, 2011, ABC News addressed 75 possible incidents of EMI on aircraft1. Keith Armstrong, in his “Banana Skins” series, has nearly 100 documented issues relating to aircraft. On December 12, 2020, a flight computer on Virgin Galactic SpaceShipTwo rebooted due to an EMI issue, causing an abort of the test flight. Thankfully, pilots C.J. Sturckow and Dave Mackay were not hurt and were able to glide to a safe landing.

Concerns about interference in commercial avionics date back to the late 1950s. A special committee of the RTCA, SC-88, with support of the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), was formed to study the use of electronics by passengers. On April 12, 1963, DO-119 was published but without regulatory limits placed on the radiation emissions of portable electronic devices. However, responsibility for assuring compliance with FAR 91.21 (was FAR 91.19 at the time) remained with the operator of the aircraft.

Feature Article
EMI Shielding and Thermal Interface Considerations for Commercial and Defense Drone Technology
Utilizing Advanced Materials to Ensure High Performance and High Reliability for UAVs
By Sierra Meloan and Ben Nudelman
open hand with a holographic drone above
A

erial drones are rapidly becoming integral to modern society, dominating headlines in combat tactics and finding widespread use across various industries. From 2020 to 2030, the global drone market is anticipated to grow at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 20%, with much of this expansion taking place in the segments of logistic drones, enterprise drones, and defense drones.

Advancements in drone technology accelerate the need to meet strict demands of lightweighting, electronics thermal management, and electromagnetic interference (EMI) shielding to ensure uncompromised signal integrity.

Types of Drones and Their Growing Applications
Before we talk about some engineering solutions to thermal management and EMI shielding challenges, let’s explore the scope of drones we’ll cover in this article. When we say drones, we’re referring to unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), which are aircraft that are meant to be operated remotely or without a human pilot on board. And while many of the examples we give will refer to drone applications, it’s important to note that the products we discuss can and are used in other drone-adjacent remote or aerial applications. This includes commercial aircraft, defense aircraft, electric aircraft, and even ground-based drone defense technology.
Feature Article
Navigating Mexico Electrical Safety Certification Requirements
A Guide to the Ever-Changing World of Mexico’s Electrical Safety Regulatory Compliance Requirements
By Claudia Cordon and John Grinager
flag of Mexico on a tablet screen
I

n our previous article, “Navigating Mexico Certification Requirements for Radio-Telecom Devices” (see In Compliance Magazine, July 2024), we outlined Mexican approval procedures for radio and telecom products from a radio-telecom compliance perspective. Separate from radio-telecom requirements, many electronic devices are subject to electrical safety compliance requirements. Fortunately, many of the organizations and processes involved in radio compliance are the same as the ones involved in safety compliance.

In this article, we will review the requirements for three safety standards in Mexico and the processes and actors involved in demonstrating compliance with those requirements. We will also explain how to obtain import documents for devices that fall outside the scope of the three standards. Finally, we will cover an important standard that is applicable to most electronic products regarding labeling, packaging, user guides, and warranties.

Feature Article
Circuit Spacings: Determining Product Safety Requirements
A Guide to Identifying and Determining Safety Critical Spacings
By Maryam Mahmoodi and Jim Bender
close up of the bronze circuitry on an dark blue motherboard

Editor’s Note: The paper on which this article is based was originally presented at the 2024 IEEE Product International Symposium on Product Compliance Engineering (ISPCE), held in Chicago, IL, in May 2024. It is reprinted here with the gracious permission of the IEEE. Copyright 2024, IEEE.

T

his article provides a simplified overview of product safety-related circuit spacings and practical methods for effectively determining when critical circuit spacings requirements may apply.

Featured examples help to illustrate applications and provide awareness of alternatives and exemptions to “classic” clearance and creepage approaches, simplifying determination and, in many cases, reducing end-product footprints through smaller printed circuit boards.

Impact of Spacings to Successfully Contribute to a Safe and Compliant Product
Circuit spacings contribute, in part, to safe and compliant products. With almost no exception, end-product and/or component-level product safety standards provide requirements for printed circuit and/or component-level spacings, commonly referred to as “creepage” and “clearance,” both critical terms to understand and differentiate.
Feature Article
Preventing Liability from Foreign‑Made Products
How to Protect Yourself When Selling Foreign Products
By Kenneth Ross
dock with cargo being loaded onto a cargo ship
A

quick look through recent 2024 recall notices posted on the website of the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) reveals that a majority of recalled products were manufactured in China.1 And a recent analysis of 1st quarter 2024 recalls by Sedgwick Brand Protection reveals the following products with the highest number of recalls – sports and recreation, children’s products, electronics, toys, and home appliances.2 Most of these products are manufactured in China or other locations in Asia.

The Hong Kong Trade Development Council (HKTDC) analyzed recalls in 2021 and had the following conclusions:

According to information collected from the CPSC consumer product recall database, there were 155 recalls involving nearly 36 million units during January‑August 2021 that either violated mandatory standards or presented a substantial risk to the public.

Imported products accounted for approximately 85.8 percent of the recalls issued (133) and about 89.1 percent of the total number of units recalled (31.8 million) during the first eight months of the year, while U.S. products accounted for 16.1 percent of the recalls issued (25) and approximately 10.9 percent of the total number of units recalled (3.9 million).

EMC concepts explained
Analysis of Transmission Lines in Sinusoidal Steady State
Different Circuit Models and Their Applications: Part 2
By Bogdan Adamczyk
T

his is the second of three articles discussing four different circuit models of transmission lines in sinusoidal steady state. In Part 1 [1], Model 1 and Model 2 were presented. In this article, we focus on Model 3. Model 3 is mathematically most expedient for evaluating the values of the minima and maxima of standing waves. The locations of the minima and maxima of standing waves are determined using Model 4.

Transmission Line Model 3
To present Model 3, it is helpful to recall Model 1, shown in Figure 1.

In Model 1, we are moving away from the source located at z = 0 towards the load located at z = L. Model 3, shown in Figure 2, is obtained from Model 1.

In this Model we are moving away from the source to the load, just like we did in Model 1. But in Model 3, the source is located at z = –L while the load is located at z = 0.

hot topics in ESD
MACHINE LEARNING APPLICATIONS IN THE NOVEL ESD COMPACT MODELING METHODOLOGY
By Wei Liang and Ahmed Ginawi for EOS/ESD Association, Inc.
Why IS ESD Compact Modeling Important
Electrostatic Discharge (ESD) is well known as one of the major reliability concerns in semiconductor manufacturing. Proper ESD protection solutions are always required to ensure integrated circuits do not fail during an ESD event. During the IC chip designing process, it is always highly desirable to have a complete set of ESD compact models of ESD protection devices that the IC designer could utilize in circuit-level SPICE simulations to achieve optimized circuit performance. It is important to predict and ensure that the ESD protection circuits and the core circuits are operating as desired, and this is key to achieving the right ESD protection solution for the first time. Therefore, the development of the ESD compact model has become one of the most essential elements in ESD device development.
What is Machine Learning?
Machine learning is a subfield of artificial intelligence (AI) that uses algorithm models to recognize the patterns in each dataset as well as learn and predict based on the supplied training dataset. It consists of a few steps, including data collection, data preparation, training, evaluation, and model tuning. Figure 1 shows the working flow of the generic machine learning concepts. Utilizing machine learning techniques will promote business success by improving time efficiency and design/prediction accuracy. In the semiconductor industry, for example, foundries are trying to apply machine learning techniques to areas like automatic defect classification, electrical tests, acoustic anomaly detection, and predictive equipment maintenance. It can also be used in EDA development, such as simulation models.
In Compliance logo
At work.
At home.
on the go.
In Compliance is here for you.
troubleshooting EMI like a pro
Using Near-Field Probes to Troubleshoot Radiated Immunity Failures
By Dr. Min Zhang
O

ur February 2024 column (refer to Reference [1], “Using a Near-Field Probe to Troubleshoot Transient Failures”) introduced a valuable technique for troubleshooting electric fast transient (EFT) failures at the PCB level. The same principle can be applied to troubleshooting radiated immunity failures. In this column, we present a case study to demonstrate these techniques.

In the following example, a company was caught by surprise when they discovered that a new IC daughterboard they designed and mounted on the original IC pinout location suffered from radiated immunity issues. The product, which is an audio device, exhibited tone distortion when exposed to radiated emissions in the 1.2 – 1.4 GHz range. The original IC had been in service for over ten years and was no longer available. The new IC, based on ARM architecture and powered by 3.3V, was intended to replace it.

The daughterboard (covering an area of approximately 374 mm2 and with a 5 mm distance to the main board) forms a capacitance of approximately 1 pF (calculated using the simple equation C=ε0εRA/h). The long trace from the daughterboard to the main board likely has an inductance of about 10nH. The self-resonance of this board is then estimated to be 1.5GHz, indicating a higher likelihood of immunity issues in this frequency range.

Banana Skins typographic title
454
Video projector interferes with audio induction loop

Installers of various equipments may not be aware of audio magnetic induction loops, which are an aid for the disabled. These produce magnetic fields across the whole audio range but primarily from 100Hz to 5kHz with a nominal field strength of 100mA/m in the listening area. Achieving this may mean fields of at least 10A/m a few centimetres from the loop cable…

455
Switch-mode power supply emissions vary strongly with mains voltage

It’s very tempting to believe the CE mark and Declaration of Conformity of a bought-in power supply, but… A power supply with active mitigation (PFC) was tested at 220V and behaved perfectly reasonably. But at the UK version of the harmonized European 230 V, actually 244 V, it drew current from only one half-cycle of the mains supply, and emitted very…

456
EM emissions from hybrid vehicles

The results from the emission testing carried out on the seven alternative powertrain vehicles have, with one exception, been found to exceed the emissions limits as specified by 95/54/EC, CIPSR 12 and 97/24/EC. The majority of the excessive emissions correspond to vertical polarisation for broadband, and the maximum frequencies for these excessive emissions…

457
Computer interferes with amateur radio

One investigation revealed a computer that was putting out a strong fifteenth harmonic on the two-meter amateur bands (144-148MHz). It was energetic enough that a mobile operator found that the resistivity of the coolant did not follow Ohm’s law. The liquid resistivity showed an increase when the electric field was increased. This phenomenon was also observed…

458
ESD in fluid lines

From 1953 to 1971 over 35 accidents involving fire and explosions in aircraft during or after fuelling were attributed to electrostatic discharge (ESD). Most of these accidents involved JP-4 hydrocarbon fuel flowing through nonconductive fuel lines with TEFLON® as the hose liner. These fluid lines consisted of an extruded Teflon tube reinforced with a braided stainless…

459
Hi-tech ambulance gear goes to waste

Millions of dollars worth of communications equipment installed in ambulances nationwide has been sitting idle for six months because it interferes with radio reception.

New Zealand’s 550 ambulances were fitted with mobile data terminals and automatic vehicle locators worth…

The EERC logo
Electrical Engineering Resource Center
Just as interference testing requires RF enclosures, isolation systems in turn need their own testing. This document reviews some of the issues and considerations in testing RF enclosures.
Is it time to renew your subscription to In Compliance?
Was this issue of In Compliance forwarded to you?
Do you only want to receive the In Compliance enewsletters?

You can do that here.

In Compliance: The Compliance information Resource for Electrical Engineers logo
Thanks for reading our November 2024 issue!